Ask questions and get answers about your city! Vote, share, review and more! Sign up

Your city: New York City (change)

hi guest (login | sign up)

Best bagel spot in Manhattan?

Brooklyn bagels are good and all, but what's the #1 spot for an authentic New York bagel in Manhattan? H&H, Ess-a-Bagel, Daniel's? You tell me!

Asked by CFan18

So what do you think? Vote below, or add another place to the list!

Flag question as inappropriate

Here's what CityVoters are saying:

IceMonkey (voted for: David's Bagels)
Useful? +4

Thumbs up

Thumbs down

A tough call between David's and the Pick-a-Bagel on 23rd/3rd, but nothing starts my day quite like David's 'everything'-and-cream-cheese bagel with a cup of strong, black coffee.
 
jwalks (voted for: H&H Bagels)
Useful? +1

Thumbs up

Thumbs down

The true best is Hoboken Bagels - but I'll let this slide cause it's in Manhatten
 
Chrispy (voted for: Tal Bagels)
Useful? +1

Thumbs up

Thumbs down

Tal Bagels get my vote -- just don't ask them to toast your bagel.
 
Grarrr (voted for: Terrace Bagels)
Useful? +0

Thumbs up

Thumbs down

Try them, try them! And you may. Try them and you may, I say!
 
Elena (voted for: Kossar's Bialys)
Useful? +0

Thumbs up

Thumbs down

Nothing better than a Bialy from Kossar's.
 
Cornflake Girl (voted for: H&H Bagels)
Useful? +0

Thumbs up

Thumbs down

The best I've had anywhere.
 

Login or sign up to comment.

Related Questions

More questions...

Ask a question

Related Local Guides

More guides...

Make my own guide

Recent votes

Other Cities

AlbanyLos Angeles
AlbuquerqueLouisville
AtlantaMemphis
AustinMiami
BaltimoreMilwaukee
BirminghamMinneapolis-St. Paul
BostonNashville
BuffaloNorfolk
CharlotteOklahoma City
ChicagoOmaha
CincinnatiOrlando
ClevelandPhiladelphia
ColumbusPhoenix
DallasPittsburgh
DenverPortland
DetroitProvidence
Grand RapidsRaleigh-Durham
GreensboroSacramento
GreenvilleSalt Lake City
HartfordSan Antonio
HonoluluSan Diego
HoustonSan Francisco
IndianapolisSeattle
JacksonvilleSt Louis
Kansas CityTampa-St. Petersburg
LancasterWashington D.C.
Las VegasWest Palm Beach